Saturday, March 21, 2009
Wednesday, March 18, 2009
The Trouble with Education
While in Indonesia last August I read a fascinatingly mind bending book called The Trouble with Physics.
I never liked physics at school, but love reading the odd pop physics book. As with all these types of books you feel that the explanations often gloss over details and make pretty large leaps of logic, which I suppose is understandable. It reminds me of reading American economics text books back in the day.
In any case, The Trouble with Physics is about how physicists became besotted with string theory in the 80s (while the rest of us became besotted with Wham!) and how String theory has stayed in vogue (even though Wham! are way past their sell buy date and we are all listening to the Jonas Brothers now).
The author, Lee Smolin, critiques string theory and says it's a load of codswallop. It turns out that string theorists have created fancy theories that are not disprovable - they may as well be disciples of the Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster!.
Smolin then talks about the Physics education system. The people that succeed are good at exams, diligent when learning the received wisdom. They are not people that think outside the box or rock the boat, because if you want an academic job you have to kowtow to your professors (I have seen this happen a few times).
And so 20 years on String theory is entrenched in theoretical physics departments everywhere. 20 years of research probably gone down the drain.
The scary thing is, the same problem exists in economics faculties (plus, economist's theories "proofs" are very very wishy washy) and probably in most academic institutions.
It's not unlike those almost alien-like hardcore religious people, with their labrynthine detailed knowledge of religious dogma.
The real danger occurs when people actually pay attention to these people steeped in string theory, religious, economic and [add social science discipline of choice] dogma.
I never liked physics at school, but love reading the odd pop physics book. As with all these types of books you feel that the explanations often gloss over details and make pretty large leaps of logic, which I suppose is understandable. It reminds me of reading American economics text books back in the day.
In any case, The Trouble with Physics is about how physicists became besotted with string theory in the 80s (while the rest of us became besotted with Wham!) and how String theory has stayed in vogue (even though Wham! are way past their sell buy date and we are all listening to the Jonas Brothers now).
The author, Lee Smolin, critiques string theory and says it's a load of codswallop. It turns out that string theorists have created fancy theories that are not disprovable - they may as well be disciples of the Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster!.
Smolin then talks about the Physics education system. The people that succeed are good at exams, diligent when learning the received wisdom. They are not people that think outside the box or rock the boat, because if you want an academic job you have to kowtow to your professors (I have seen this happen a few times).
And so 20 years on String theory is entrenched in theoretical physics departments everywhere. 20 years of research probably gone down the drain.
The scary thing is, the same problem exists in economics faculties (plus, economist's theories "proofs" are very very wishy washy) and probably in most academic institutions.
It's not unlike those almost alien-like hardcore religious people, with their labrynthine detailed knowledge of religious dogma.
The real danger occurs when people actually pay attention to these people steeped in string theory, religious, economic and [add social science discipline of choice] dogma.
Harvard’s masters of the apocalypse
No one gets fired for hiring a Harvard graduate, or so the saying goes. Same thing applies for lots of professional qualifications, CFA, CPA etc.
Thing is, what are you actually learning? It's all just cookie-cutter education, designed to help the HR drones to safely hire you without much worry and open the gates to earning lots of money (or so the theory goes).
People should spend their time studying what they are passionate about, rather what will earn 'em big money.
Sunday, February 22, 2009
Saturday, February 21, 2009
Thug Culture
I need to learn about Preman in Indonesia.
Preman are the local thugs that you pay protection money to.
Indonesia's police have been more or less worthless, so it sort of sense that a locality's security is somewhat privatised. Even though you are paying money to some kind of local mafia.
In any case, vice president (and presidential candidate) Kalla has said Indonesia needs a Preman to run the country not a bureaucrat. Maybe something gets lost in translation.
As I said, I need to learn more about this.
Preman are the local thugs that you pay protection money to.
Indonesia's police have been more or less worthless, so it sort of sense that a locality's security is somewhat privatised. Even though you are paying money to some kind of local mafia.
In any case, vice president (and presidential candidate) Kalla has said Indonesia needs a Preman to run the country not a bureaucrat. Maybe something gets lost in translation.
As I said, I need to learn more about this.
Lampung
My pal, Ayu, has written up a little about her recent travels through Lampung.
Hopefully there will be more to come!!
Hopefully there will be more to come!!
Sunday, February 01, 2009
Breaking up Indonesia
I remember when I first went to Bali.
I had been living with my ex girlfriend's family in Jakarta for a couple of weeks. They were great, in fact more than great, I think that family is directly responsible for my love of Indonesia.
Nevertheless Jakarta was a huge shock to the system : ) I do not mind eating rice for example, but having it e.v.e.r.y. day was tough going!!
Then we went to Jogja for a few days, and that was good. But we were staying at a friend's family's house, and being my first time in a Muslim country, the conservativeness was kind of getting to me (I had lived in Germany for years, the difference was huge!).
So when we reached Bali, we could be ourselves, eat Western food. I loved it.
Westerner's perceptions of Bali are weird.
I remember one of my friends complaining about a Westerner who thought Bali was an independent country.In Ireland, Bali is typically known as a honeymoon spot, which is kind of weird if you think about it.
For me Bali is just a wondiverous place and associating it specifically with honeymooning takes away from its depth and richness.
At least, Bali is known for *something* though, the point is its image is not subsumed in the Indonesian blamange.
Whenever Indonesia gets its tourist marketing strategy up to speed it will market each island individually. If Bali is known for honeymooning (yuck, really yuck!) Java will be known for the shopping malls of Jakarta and the Batika of Jogja and Solo; Sumatra for it's landscapes; Kalimantan for adventure and wildlife holidays; Manado for diving.
I am just pulling these ideas from thin air, but you get the idea. The marketing will be largely inaccurate (as with most marketing) but these ideas will stick in people's heads. You want to dive, head to Manado, you want to see wildlife head to Kalimantan, you want to shop head to Java.
The names Java or Sumatra or Manado can conjure up much more interesting visions than Indonesia. Indonesia has to drop it's unity in diversity if it wants to attract visitors.
I had been living with my ex girlfriend's family in Jakarta for a couple of weeks. They were great, in fact more than great, I think that family is directly responsible for my love of Indonesia.
Nevertheless Jakarta was a huge shock to the system : ) I do not mind eating rice for example, but having it e.v.e.r.y. day was tough going!!
Then we went to Jogja for a few days, and that was good. But we were staying at a friend's family's house, and being my first time in a Muslim country, the conservativeness was kind of getting to me (I had lived in Germany for years, the difference was huge!).
So when we reached Bali, we could be ourselves, eat Western food. I loved it.
Westerner's perceptions of Bali are weird.
I remember one of my friends complaining about a Westerner who thought Bali was an independent country.In Ireland, Bali is typically known as a honeymoon spot, which is kind of weird if you think about it.
For me Bali is just a wondiverous place and associating it specifically with honeymooning takes away from its depth and richness.
At least, Bali is known for *something* though, the point is its image is not subsumed in the Indonesian blamange.
Whenever Indonesia gets its tourist marketing strategy up to speed it will market each island individually. If Bali is known for honeymooning (yuck, really yuck!) Java will be known for the shopping malls of Jakarta and the Batika of Jogja and Solo; Sumatra for it's landscapes; Kalimantan for adventure and wildlife holidays; Manado for diving.
I am just pulling these ideas from thin air, but you get the idea. The marketing will be largely inaccurate (as with most marketing) but these ideas will stick in people's heads. You want to dive, head to Manado, you want to see wildlife head to Kalimantan, you want to shop head to Java.
The names Java or Sumatra or Manado can conjure up much more interesting visions than Indonesia. Indonesia has to drop it's unity in diversity if it wants to attract visitors.
Sunday, January 25, 2009
Selamat
Just spotted this.
That's one of the great things about Jakarta and Indonesia, it's such a melting pot of cultures and people, it's a fascinating country.
Hat tip to Everything Indonesia.
That's one of the great things about Jakarta and Indonesia, it's such a melting pot of cultures and people, it's a fascinating country.
Hat tip to Everything Indonesia.
Sunday, January 18, 2009
Sunday, January 11, 2009
Wednesday, December 31, 2008
Virus
I have been knocked down with a cold / flu virus for the past few days (what's the difference between a cold and the flu actually?).
Two things struck me.
It's been about 3 years since the last time I have been sick, you kinda forget how crappy being sick is. I have been way too blithe when pals have told me they came down with typhus, dengue, measles or whatnot (really bad stuff).
Viruses are pretty smart. Cold viruses are all about mind control. They cause you to sneeze somehow and then find new hosts. Ingenious. I wonder how they do that?
Tuesday, December 30, 2008
Defending Indonesia's Corruption Record
A while back, I was lying in a hotel room in Bandung. BBC World business report was on in the background, when on came an Indonesian government representative.
Immediately I sat up. I am like that, being an Indonesia geek.
This Indonesian guy was promoting business in Indonesia.
Niceties over, the interviewer clobbered the Indonesian guy, with something like,
"Indonesia recently scored near bottom of transparency international's corruption index. That won't give international firms confidence in investing in Indonesia, will it?"
The guy floundered.
"We're improving yada yada yada"
"Doesn't look that way to me"
Needless to say it did not sound at all convincing.
Not that I like defending Indonesia's transparency international corruption ranking, but you could go about it as follows.
Transparency International reports on people's perceptions of corruption. Is it any wonder that Indonesians are more keenly aware of wrongs when they are reported on everyday in a mostly free manner. Indonesia has a problem, but at least its people are keenly aware of it, unlike many other places with lobotomised media (Singapore's Straits Times, anyone?).
It's a bit like Alcoholics Anonymous, you gotta be aware your problem before you can overcome it.
Countries with freer media will ironically tend to have worse Transparency International Corruption ranks.
Immediately I sat up. I am like that, being an Indonesia geek.
This Indonesian guy was promoting business in Indonesia.
Niceties over, the interviewer clobbered the Indonesian guy, with something like,
"Indonesia recently scored near bottom of transparency international's corruption index. That won't give international firms confidence in investing in Indonesia, will it?"
The guy floundered.
"We're improving yada yada yada"
"Doesn't look that way to me"
Needless to say it did not sound at all convincing.
Not that I like defending Indonesia's transparency international corruption ranking, but you could go about it as follows.
Transparency International reports on people's perceptions of corruption. Is it any wonder that Indonesians are more keenly aware of wrongs when they are reported on everyday in a mostly free manner. Indonesia has a problem, but at least its people are keenly aware of it, unlike many other places with lobotomised media (Singapore's Straits Times, anyone?).
It's a bit like Alcoholics Anonymous, you gotta be aware your problem before you can overcome it.
Countries with freer media will ironically tend to have worse Transparency International Corruption ranks.
Through a Glass Darkly
Over and over, pals tell me how Suharto era Indonesia was a safer Indonesia than present day.
Obviously you have to ignore the goings on in Timor Leste, Aceh and Papua during Suharto's reign.
You would have to forget how Suharto got going - by killing a cool half a million people or more. And how he went out, by sending thugs to rape and murder Chinese Indonesians.
Also, you would have to turn a blind eye to the Suharto incorporated mafia monopoly. He gave the license to one man, a thug called Yapto. Needless to say, Yapto is kinda like the Voldemort "he who shall not be named" of Indonesia today.
I have little idea whether the Indonesian archipelago is safer than it was 15 or 20 years ago. It's difficult or impossible for me to call. But I suspect it is difficult for most Indonesians to make judgements that go much further than personal anecdotes either.
Indonesia's press was locked down back then. Now, for better or worse, Indonesia has the freest press in South East Asia.
Perceptions count for a lot.
Obviously you have to ignore the goings on in Timor Leste, Aceh and Papua during Suharto's reign.
You would have to forget how Suharto got going - by killing a cool half a million people or more. And how he went out, by sending thugs to rape and murder Chinese Indonesians.
Also, you would have to turn a blind eye to the Suharto incorporated mafia monopoly. He gave the license to one man, a thug called Yapto. Needless to say, Yapto is kinda like the Voldemort "he who shall not be named" of Indonesia today.
I have little idea whether the Indonesian archipelago is safer than it was 15 or 20 years ago. It's difficult or impossible for me to call. But I suspect it is difficult for most Indonesians to make judgements that go much further than personal anecdotes either.
Indonesia's press was locked down back then. Now, for better or worse, Indonesia has the freest press in South East Asia.
Perceptions count for a lot.
Sunday, December 28, 2008
Gaza
I have heard that Israel's bombing of Gaza is partly due to the Israeli government wanting to show a hardline in the run up to elections.
But could Obama taking over in the US also be a factor? Would not be surprised.
But could Obama taking over in the US also be a factor? Would not be surprised.
Saturday, December 27, 2008
2008
Every year I seem to get sucked into year end nostalgia. Here's this year's dose.
Best song. Hold on to Yourself, by Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds. From the Dig Lazarus Dig!!! album. Just found out it's about escapologists (messrs. Lazarus and Houdini) based in New York. How fitting.
Best buy of the year. A pair of JVC marshmallow ear-plug-like earphones. They cost about 15 quid. Bought them in Dublin airport before heading off to the R of I on January 1st.
99% of background noise vanishes. I never walk on a plane without 'em now.
Best football match. Persija (Jakarta's biggest football team) v Persipura (from Papua, i.e. straight outta the jungle! ; )). The Persipura 11 were awesome. Eighty odd thousand Jakmania in Gelora Bung Karno were equally awesome though. Indonesian football is a relfection of the place. Once done right, I am sure Indonesian football will be huge! Thing is, it's pretty messed up at the moment. Thanks to the Jakarta Casual for getting me tickets.
I have read a few great books this year, less so now I am in New York and not commuting (I work and live on the same street). Things the Grandchildren Should Know is a book about Mark Everitt, the Eels frontman. I've never been a huge Eels fan, but it doesn't matter, it's mostly about his messed up life, family and how he loved them.
More to come!
Best song. Hold on to Yourself, by Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds. From the Dig Lazarus Dig!!! album. Just found out it's about escapologists (messrs. Lazarus and Houdini) based in New York. How fitting.
Best buy of the year. A pair of JVC marshmallow ear-plug-like earphones. They cost about 15 quid. Bought them in Dublin airport before heading off to the R of I on January 1st.
99% of background noise vanishes. I never walk on a plane without 'em now.
Best football match. Persija (Jakarta's biggest football team) v Persipura (from Papua, i.e. straight outta the jungle! ; )). The Persipura 11 were awesome. Eighty odd thousand Jakmania in Gelora Bung Karno were equally awesome though. Indonesian football is a relfection of the place. Once done right, I am sure Indonesian football will be huge! Thing is, it's pretty messed up at the moment. Thanks to the Jakarta Casual for getting me tickets.
I have read a few great books this year, less so now I am in New York and not commuting (I work and live on the same street). Things the Grandchildren Should Know is a book about Mark Everitt, the Eels frontman. I've never been a huge Eels fan, but it doesn't matter, it's mostly about his messed up life, family and how he loved them.
More to come!
Wednesday, December 24, 2008
Worrying about Genetalia
Pope Benedict is God's representative on earth.
He doesn't like gay people.
This guy loves to think himself as an intelectual. So obviously there's a totally rational reason for his homophobia.
It's genius, we never heard of this before, don't panic, but it's er... **HUMAN EXTINCTION**.
Shite!! It's the big one.
If only we had some totally non camp James Bond to save us from our gays. I.e. more Timothy Dalton than Roger Moore.
So there you have it, the world is turning gay, be afraid. Be very afraid.
He doesn't like gay people.
This guy loves to think himself as an intelectual. So obviously there's a totally rational reason for his homophobia.
It's genius, we never heard of this before, don't panic, but it's er... **HUMAN EXTINCTION**.
Shite!! It's the big one.
If only we had some totally non camp James Bond to save us from our gays. I.e. more Timothy Dalton than Roger Moore.
So there you have it, the world is turning gay, be afraid. Be very afraid.
Sunday, December 21, 2008
Mixing and Mashing
I think the Forum from the BBC World Service is now my favourite program on my favourite radio station.
It can be hit and miss but it's mostly pretty interesting.
By the way, anyone heard the recent interview by Alan Johnson with Ingrid Betancourt? I think it is the best interview I have heard in a long long time.
It can be hit and miss but it's mostly pretty interesting.
By the way, anyone heard the recent interview by Alan Johnson with Ingrid Betancourt? I think it is the best interview I have heard in a long long time.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)